Skip to content
FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THINGS TECH
Technology

deVere puts consumer staples valuation at highest since 1998

Hero visual representing deVere puts consumer staples valuation at highest since 1998
Featured visual for deVere puts consumer staples valuation at highest since 1998

The Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund fell 0.43% on November 12, 2026, a day after deVere Group estimated that consumer staples were trading at their highest forward earnings valuation since 1998. The decline came alongside losses of 0.35% for the S&P 500 and 0.39% for the Nasdaq Composite.

In its November 11 assessment, deVere put staples at about 23.8 times forward earnings, compared with below 21 times a year earlier. It also placed large US technology stocks near 23 times expected 2026 earnings.

The group said global consumer staples gained 10.6% in October, their strongest month since 1998, while global healthcare rose 9.8%, its second-largest monthly increase this century.

The assessment followed a sharp October divergence between technology stocks and companies selling groceries, drinks and household goods. DeVere chief executive Nigel Green warned that investors moving out of technology had concentrated their buying in a relatively small group of defensive stocks.

October gains widened the gap with technology

The Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund, known by its ticker XLP, gained 10.9% in October, its strongest month since its December 1998 launch. The Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund, or XLK, fell 8.3%. The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, or SPY, declined 0.9%.

October 2026 price changes, September 30 to October 30 closing prices
Fund Ticker Change
Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund XLP +10.9%
SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust SPY -0.9%
Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund XLK -8.3%

The completed-month figures put XLP about 19.2 percentage points ahead of XLK and 11.8 points ahead of SPY. These fund comparisons measure price changes only. Walmart gained 18.9% over October.

The shift was visible before the month ended. At 3:10 p.m. Eastern time on October 22, Walmart shares were up 16.2% for the month, Procter & Gamble had gained 14.6%, Colgate-Palmolive 14%, Costco 11.5% and Coca-Cola 10.6%. These intramonth readings preceded the final October closes.

Bank of America equity quant strategist Jill Carey Hall said the bank’s clients sold a record $14.8 billion of individual US stocks in the week through October 16. Technology recorded its second-largest outflows, while staples were among the few sectors clients bought. The figures describe the bank’s client activity rather than all trading across the US stock market.

Earnings growth and costs frame the valuation

Green said staples earnings had grown by less than 5% annually over the preceding decade, while dividend yields were among their lowest since 2005. DeVere’s valuation assessment therefore paired a higher earnings multiple with relatively modest historical profit growth.

Procter & Gamble’s October 22 results provided a company-level picture. For its fiscal 2027 first quarter, covering July through September 2026, P&G reported core earnings of $2.00 a share, up 1% from a year earlier. Net sales increased 4% to $23.28 billion, while total volume rose 2.4%.

The company forecast approximately $1.4 billion in after-tax commodity cost pressures for fiscal 2027. It attributed the expected headwind to higher raw-material, energy and transportation costs. Chief financial officer Andre Schulten said prolonged high oil prices meant materially higher cost pressures in the second quarter and second half of the fiscal year.

Banks differ on the technology selloff

Bank of America’s equity derivatives strategists described the AI selloff as largely driven by positioning at the edges of the trade, rather than evidence of underlying weakness at its core. The team also placed healthcare and staples among the highest readings on its Bubble Risk Indicator. The positioning assessment addressed the nature of the AI selloff, while the indicator highlighted risks within the sectors attracting defensive buying.

Citi took a more cautious position on technology, cutting US and global technology stocks from overweight to neutral. Its stated reasons included wider credit spreads and weaker earnings revisions.

A technology rebound on November 9 had already produced a different pattern. In its November 11 assessment, deVere cited a 2.35% rise in the S&P 500 that day, a 3.73% technology gain and a 0.90% increase for staples. That session preceded the shared declines on November 12.